Who would have thought that the Jetsons were right and we would try to get everything from one pill? Whether you are eating a poor diet and trying to fill in the gaps with a multivitamin, or eating a balanced diet and taking a multivitamin for insurance against deficiency, dietary supplements in the form of a multivitamin are a part of more than 30 percent of an American’s diet. Are multivitamins necessary? This is a common question for average humans and athletes alike, and a popular topic in the medical field. Below we will explain how we determined the best and worst mulitvitamins for 2019.
How Are Multivitamins Made?
You will find the following processes that are used to make a multivitamin: whole food, naturally derived and modified, synthesized from yeast or fermentation. Typically there isn’t a multivitamin that doesn’t contain some synthesized or “scientifically formulated” nutrients since they cannot be reached to high enough levels from food to hit the target amounts. For 2019, the best and worst multivitamins show that the best are moving more towards whole food sources.
The majority of “whole food multivitamins” actually use a nutrient-rich broth, added synthetic vitamins and the yeast saccharomyces to metabolize and convert them, then use small amounts of fruit or vegetable blends as filler. The difference is if those forms are in the biologically available and active form. This is where the claims can fall in a gray area. There are certain synthetic dietary supplements like vitamin E and beta carotene that have performed poorly and at a detriment in studies, whereas L-ascorbic acid has performed very well. Magnesium citrate, malate, and glycinate show superior absorption over oxide or carbonate forms.
The Major Studies on Multivitamins
1. A large randomized double placebo clinical trial in 2012 looking at 16,451 male doctors over 50 with a history of cancer followed for more than a decade found that those who took a multivitamin had an 8% lower incidence of cancer returning, however, it did not have any effect on prostate cancer or men without a history of cancer. It also did not show any reduction in heart attacks or strokes.
2. A 2006 study looked at the efficacy and safety of multivitamin and mineral supplement use to prevent cancer and chronic disease in adults. In a poorly nourished Chinese population, combined supplementation with beta-carotene, alpha-tocopherol, and selenium reduced the incidence of and mortality rate from gastric cancer and the overall mortality rate from cancer by 13% to 21%.
In a French trial, combined supplementation with vitamin C, vitamin E, beta-carotene, selenium, and zinc reduced the rate of cancer by 31% in men but not in women. Multivitamin and mineral supplements had no significant effect on cardiovascular disease or cataracts, except that combined beta carotene, selenium, alpha-tocopherol, retinol, and zinc supplementation reduced the mortality rate from stroke by 29%.
A combination of 7 vitamins and minerals stabilized visual acuity loss in a small trial, and combined zinc and antioxidants slowed the progression of advanced age-related macular degeneration in high-risk persons. No consistent adverse effects of multivitamin and mineral supplements were evident, and the conclusion was that it couldn’t be proven or disproven if multivitamins helped prevent cancer or chronic disease.
3. The study from JAMA looked at 68 trials with over 230,000 participants taking different varieties of antioxidants (A, C, E, beta carotene, selenium) and concluded that “treatment with beta carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin E may increase mortality. The potential roles of vitamin C and selenium on mortality need further study.”
Anyone that has read numerous positive studies on vitamin C might have frowned at that conclusion. A closer inspection shows that the cherry picking of these studies looks like something Inspector Clouseau might have worked on.
According to Dr. Houston from Vanderbuilt Medical School, “from an original pool of 815 studies, the researchers excluded a whopping 747 of them (91.5%) for one reason or another, leaving just 8% on which to base their conclusions. Of the excluded studies, 405 were rejected simply because none of the participants in these studies had died. But how can the researchers possibly prove that antioxidants have no effect on mortality if they’ve eliminated almost half of the studies in the data pool specifically because there was no mortality?”
In all the final studies pooled, the antioxidants were synthetic and chronically ill people were mixed in with healthy people. Closer inspection shows a VERY wide dosage from only 60mg of vitamin C to 200,000 IU of vitamin E in a single day! Professor Balz Frei, the Director of the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University commented on the study saying “all the new study really demonstrates is a bias toward identifying studies or research that show harm caused by antioxidants, and selective removal of research that shows benefits.”
Do You Need a Multivitamin?
A better question is “do you need a multi-mineral?” A standardized daily allowance has created a skewed perception of our individual requirements and what is provided by the soil our food was grown in. Dr. Linus Pauling, winner of two Nobel Prizes once said, “You can trace every sickness, every disease and every ailment to a mineral deficiency.” While I cannot find the document online, the chemist Raymond Francis in his book Never Fear Cancer Again states “a 1992 Earth Summit Report suggested that 99 percent of Americans are mineral deficient.”
What about vitamins? Water-soluble vitamins like all of the b-vitamins and vitamin C are what I see to be a major problem due to the lack of access to freshly picked foods. Both of these deplete quickly post-harvest, and the majority of clients I see are deficient in these nutrients. Magnesium is also a major mineral lacking in our water and soil. On the other side, people may need to avoid folic acid (synthetic form) in fortified foods and in multivitamins because it blocks folate receptors if they have a slow DHFR enzyme and have a homozygous MTHFR C677T gene Be careful with methylfolate dosage and don’t assume that more is always better.
Top 5 Arguments for Vitamin and Mineral Supplements
1. Chemical agriculture has depleted, polluted and destroyed the soil and our water supply. If the minerals are not in the soil, they are not in the food. If the water is stripped of its minerals and polluted, and crop rotation and composting is not practiced, then the food is in a sorry state to begin with. Vitamins are highest when foods are freshly picked, and many decline rapidly post-harvest, both chemically and organically grown. Worldwide shipping and storage of fruits and vegetables give us further depleted food.
- Glyphosphate (potent herbicide on GMO crops) blocks calcium, magnesium, manganese and iron from being absorbed in genetically modified grains, fruits, legumes and vegetables
- Spinach and asparagus lose 50-70 percent of their folate when kept at room temperature for three days.
- Vegetables such as asparagus, broccoli, and green beans typically lose 50 percent of their vitamin C before they reach the produce counter
- Potatoes lose as much as 78 percent of their vitamin C during long-term storage at 36 degrees.
- Nitrogen fertilizers used in non-organic agriculture may lower vitamin C content in fruits and vegetables
- Blanching of vegetables prior to freezing can destroy half the vitamins
- Freezing meat can destroy up to 70 percent of its vitamins
2. We are no longer growing our own food or collecting it from the wild fresh. Processed food has become a staple for a large percentage of the population, feeding people food that is calorie rich and nutrient poor. Very few people can obtain a daily diet based on our hunter-gatherer and farming ancestors.
3. Sugar, refined carbohydrates, stress, coffee, and alcohol consumption has created depletion on top of toxicity.
4. A highly chemical environment, diet, medications, and personal care products have put new demands on the human body that it has never had to deal with the history of mankind. Deficiencies of certain minerals increase the uptake of heavy metals. Lead will take the place of calcium, cadmium will take the place of zinc, aluminum will take the place of magnesium, and nickel will take the place of manganese.
5. An indoor, sedentary, high-stress environment puts additional demands on the body that increase the need for numerous vitamins and minerals that are also needed to offset the toxic byproducts of stress hormones.
Top 5 Arguments Against Multivitamins
1. They don’t work.
Answer: One standard formula for an entire population is bound to fail for those with individual biochemical needs where it may only take one nutrient or mineral needed in higher amounts to make the difference.
2. You can get all the RDA vitamins and minerals from food. Supplements are not necessary.
Answer: Remember that the RDA is the absolute minimum needed to prevent things like scurvy, not the amount required for optimal health. However, you can get above the RDA for certain vitamins and minerals with a good diet.
3. They cause more harm than good.
Answer: This could be true for formulas using food dyes, artificial sweeteners, toxic forms and high amounts of certain vitamins and minerals. Pharmaceuticals are connected to over 125,000 deaths per year. According to the U.S. National Poison Data System, there were zero deaths linked to supplementation as of 2010. Y
You can find thousands of clinical studies showing the efficacy of supplementation without side effects or toxicity. You cannot compare a cheap synthetic vitamin in the wrong form or toxic forms of antioxidants with the form found in nature and call them equivalent. Each time vitamin E and beta carotene is brought up to cause harm in studies, people fail to mention the ones used were synthetically made into the wrong form and have no biological activity.
4. Many people consume too many calories, and therefore are able to get the extra amount of vitamins and minerals required.
Answer: Not likely. We are a calorie rich and nutrient poor nation. We are creating more vitamin and mineral deficiencies due the depletion caused by sugar and refined flour based carbohydrates (depletes b-vitamins, vitamin C, magnesium and calcium just to name a few).
5. If you need extra vitamins, you should eat fortified foods.
Answer: You will not find dieticians recommending supplements, but you will find them recommending fortified foods. Let the irony settle in for a minute. Why would they say not to take supplements, but to choose food with added poorly made synthetic vitamins? Because the American Dietetic Association is funded by processed food companies. This is how a diet of fortified cereal, fortified orange juice, low-fat dairy and artificial sweeteners became forced on the public. This is also why many will not use the dietician title now due to the loss of credibility.
How Nutrigenomic DNA Nutrition Testing Can Help
My opinion is that multivitamins may actually prevent people from choosing more nutrient-dense foods in their diet and continue bad eating habits, using a multivitamin as false insurance. How do you know which vitamins you are lacking?
The way you find out exactly which ones are most likely missing is going to be strictly due to the individual’s food choices, physical activity, soil mineral levels, cooking preparation, constitution, genetic biochemistry, stress, environmental pollutants and other factors. In other words, challenging without a professional analysis. What we do know is that there are certain vitamins and minerals that are harder to get in today’s world and require a much higher need for the majority.
What do the majority of multivitamins lack? Calcium, magnesium, choline, enough vitamin C, K2, omega-3 fatty acids, sufficient iodine, b-vitamins in the active bioavailable form, vitamin E in all eight forms, true vitamin A (not just beta carotene) and enough vitamin D.
If you are interested in determining where you have higher needs for certain vitamins, mineral and compounds at a genetic level, I spent years developing nutrigenomic software to help find these answers. It has been by far been the most life-changing testing I have done for myself and thousands of others. Click on the images below to read more or go straight to Nutrition Genome.
The Worst Multivitamins for 2020
While supplements are immune from the death statistics, they are not without their problems. While it’s not proven that supplements were the main cause, Consumer Reports states that 6,300 serious adverse events were possibly associated with supplements.
I wouldn’t be surprised if some supplements are associated with adverse effects because without regulation and accountability, untested products are going to find their way in mainstream stores. Everyone has different sensitivities, and certain additives and versions of vitamins can cause issues for some but not others. You need to do your homework on reputable companies that do purity tests and clinical studies backing up their claims.
One incident happened to Gary Null, who was almost killed by his own product when Gary Null’s Ultimate Power Meal almost became his last meal with an overdose of vitamin D (2 million instead of 2 thousand IU). Another example occurred with a liquid multivitamin that had 200 times the amount of selenium (40,800mcg) that it should of, leading to acute selenium toxicity in chiropractor patients. For the best and worst multivitamins of 2019 list, you want to pay attention to why the worst were chosen, and use these guidelines if choosing a multivitamin not on the best list.
The following matched one or more of the previous criteria for my opinion of the worst multi-vitamins:
1. Flintstones Vitamins: When I was a child, my mom (also a nutritionist) would do lectures using Flintstones vitamins as an example of what not to buy. She would take a lighter to the vitamins and it would melt down to a mound resembling oil, from the coal based artificial colors. The #1 children’s multivitamin in the US and the top vitamin recommended by Pediatricians is produced by the pharmaceutical company Bayer and contains the neurotoxin aspartame, cupric oxide (a potentially toxic form of copper), coal tar artificial colors, hydrogenated GMO soybean oil and GMO corn starch.
2. Centrum Multi-Vitamin/Mineral: Made by the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, and brings in close to 1 billion in sales. Centrum uses synthetic vitamin E (dl-alpha-tocopherol) and beta carotene, the same kind that has been found to cause detrimental health problems like prostate and lung cancer. It uses the oxide form of magnesium, which only 4% is absorbed. It contains hydrogenated palm oil, a trans-fat highly correlated to heart disease, not to mention all the horrible artificial colors including FD#C Blue #2, Yellow #6 and Red #40 found to disrupt mitochondrial function (the power house of a cell).
A study published in the Journal of Food and Chemical Toxicology found that the dyes actually enter the bloodstream through the skin or digestive system, debunking previous expertise that the skin blocked it and the digestive system destroyed it first. This is alarming because these dyes have already been linked to ADHD, allergies, and asthma, but due to the dye’s ability to inhibit cellular respiration, a whole cascade of health effects.
3. Bayer One a Day: Vitamin A is labeled (14% as beta carotene). When the source of the beta carotene is not listed, that means it may be synthetic.
Synthetic versions of beta carotene have been shown to increase the risk of cancer in heavy smokers and drinkers, and accelerated the death and shortened the life span of rats exposed to radiation. But the natural form of beta carotene decreased the death rate and significantly increased the life span of exposed rats. Synthetic vitamin E is used and seen as dl-alpha-tocopherol acetate. It has been shown to have little or no anticancer effectiveness, and may even increase prostate cancer. Magnesium oxide and zinc oxide are used, a poor choice for men especially.
4. Nutrilite™ Double X™ Vitamin/Mineral/Phytonutrient Supplement by Amway: The Nutrilite Double X multivitamin by Amway is priced at $87 for a 31-day supply, with a vitamin and mineral formulation that costs as little to make as possible. The multivitamin uses a source of beta-carotene that is not listed, folic acid, cyanocobalamin, magnesium oxide, zinc oxide, and synthetic vitamin E (dl-alpha-tocopherol). There are a lot of additives in the other ingredient section like soybean oil, glucose syrup and sucrose as well. While they did a lot of research on the plant concentrate section, they need to match the vitamin and mineral profile with the same quality and price it appropriately.
Here is the full list of non-medicinal ingredients: Acacia, Agar, Ascorbyl Palmitate, Calcium Stearate, Calcium Sulfate, Carnauba Wax, Corn Starch, Croscarmellose Sodium, Calcium Phosphate, Dibasic, dl-Alpha Tocopherol, Glucose Syrup, Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose, Glycerin, Magnesium Stearate, Maltodextrin, Medium Chain Triglycerides, Microcrystalline Cellulose, Mixed Tocopherol Concentrate, Unhydrogenated Palm Oil, Pea Starch, Silicon Dioxide, Sodium Alginate, Sodium Ascorbate, Soy protein isolate, Sucrose, Pectin, Soybean Oil, Dicalcium Phosphate, Corn Starch Modified, Powdered Cellulose, Gum Arabic.
5. GNC Ultra Mega Gold: This formula has many carbonate and oxide forms, and in particular copper, magnesium and zinc in oxide form in my book are considered “bad form.” While this is detrimental for women and men for different reasons, men especially need good sources of magnesium and zinc for the heart and prostate. Make sure you are getting citrate, malate glycinate or picolinate forms.
There are many ingredients that look added for the wow factor, but almost all of them are so low that they are insignificant. While the tocotrienol complex is admirable, 900 micrograms is not going to do much when the effective dose starts at 375 milligrams or more according to A.C. Grace. On the other ingredient section, it says “sucralose” while below it states “no artificial flavors.” Get the facts straight GNC. These should obviously be avoided, but why would you put artificial flavors in something that you are not even eating? It’s maddening.
6. PaleoBalance All in One WholeFoods Multi-Vitamin: You are probably shocked to hear me put a multi-vitamin with the name “Paleo” in it on the bad list. Well, thou shall not use the word Paleo in vain. As I have learned more about the manufacturing process, I have learned how to spot companies cutting corners to create a cheaper product.
If you look at the label closely, there is nothing impressive about the vitamin and mineral profile. The oxide and carbonate forms are the cheapest to use, and also the most poorly absorbed (only 10 percent of oxide forms are absorbed). Magnesium and zinc use the oxide forms in their formula (both important for neurotransmitter health) and the calcium used is carbonate.
Vitamin E should also be used with mixed tocopherols, not just d-alpha. The vitamin D is D2 (often synthetic) while D3 is considered to be much more effective. Iron is missing, so if you are female you will want something with iron. Vitamin K is missing, which is probably the first time I’ve seen a multi-vitamin missing vitamin K.
PaleoBalance uses cheap vitamins and minerals, and from what I can see non-organic blends. In general, blends are usually very small amounts, so I question how effective these are in the first place and I suspect they are added for marketing. If you look at the omega 3 profile, it is plant-based (only 11mg of ALA, barely if any will convert to EPA and DHA where 200-300mg are usually standard). After receiving multiple emails about this product, I wanted to set the record straight that this isn’t what I would deem up to Paleo standards.
The Best Multivitamins and Multiminerals for 2020
After numerous comments and emails, I have been on the search for years to give a recommendation for a basic daily multivitamin supplement that is worth purchasing. Not only do you want the right formulation, but you want to see GMP certification and other documentation to assure the product produced has the identity, strength, composition, quality, and purity that it is represented on the label.
If you are looking for specific multivitamins for athletes, executives, children or seniors, I recommend the following articles:
The Best Multivitamins for Athletes and Executives
The Best Children’s Multivitamins
Best and Worst Multivitamins for Seniors
You can choose either a multivitamin or a multimineral based on your needs. The multivitamin contains both vitamins and minerals, while the multimineral only contains minerals, but higher amounts of calcium and magnesium.
If you are looking for a multivitamin that gives a foundational amount of vitamins and minerals in the right form, I have narrowed it down to these four. Remember to take your multivitamin with food so that you absorb the carotenoids and fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K.
Cost: $39.99 for 120 capsules (4 capsules daily)
This is the 2020 leading multivitamin and mineral formula based on the new FDA daily value guidelines. The creators of this formula took very careful consideration to utilize whole food organic ingredients while also recognizing the research for including the optimal forms of certain vitamins and minerals that may not be stable or absorbed well from the plant kingdom.
If you are willing to pay more for an organic whole food based good multivitamin that also provides the optimal sources and forms of each vitamin and mineral, this is the one. While a close tie with Naturelo, the nose over the finish line is the included lithium, Gotu kola over the use of ginkgo (ginkgo can interact with medications), boron, and saw palmetto (for men). This formula also follows the standards for a vegan multivitamin.
- The only multivitamin that has a 300mcg microdose of lithium orotate for folate and B12 transport, neuron protection, cognitive function, mood improvement, and inflammatory regulation
- Beta carotene from D. salina, a superior source of full-spectrum carotenoids
- Vitamin A palmitate – preformed vitamin A for healthy DNA, cell differentiation, lung health, immune function, skin and eye health and digestive tract lining. Helpful form for those who have a poor conversion of beta-carotene into this active form of vitamin A as seen in the Nutrition Genome Report.
- Vitamin E as d-alpha-tocopherol succinate for lung health, skin health, and anti-inflammatory actions
- Vitamin D3, K2, calcium, magnesium, and boron for bone health
- K2 as Menaquinone-7 for cardiovascular health
- B2 as R-5-P, B6 as P-5-P, folate as methylfolate and B12 as methylcobalamin for healthy methylation and homocysteine levels
- A higher amount of magnesium (250mg) for heart health and energy (ATP) production
- Iodine from Icelandic kelp
- Correct dosing and use of mineral chelates (zinc 12mg, selenium 55mcg, manganese 2.3mg, copper 0.8mg) for a wider population
- Digestive enzyme blend for better assimilation of nutrients
- Gotu Kola for cognition, circulation and skin repair
- The antioxidant blend (lutein, lycopene, zeaxanthin, astaxanthin, grapeseed extract, bilberry, green tea leaf extract) and choline + fruit and vegetable blends provide some anti-inflammatory support through each decade of life
- The men’s version contains saw palmetto for a healthy prostate
- Made in FDA registered facility, GMP certified and third-party tested
- No harmful additives or fillers
- Capsules can be opened and added to smoothie, drink or food
What you may need in addition to this multivitamin: calcium and vitamin D depending on your blood work and medical situation.
Cost: $44.95 for 120 capsules (4 daily)
Budget-Friendly One-A-Day Foundation Version:
The Naturelo One-A-Day is a good multivitamin if you are looking for basic levels of vitamins and minerals on a budget.
Cost: $19.95 for 60 capsules and one capsule daily
The creators of this formula took very careful consideration to utilize whole food organic ingredients while also recognizing the research for including the optimal forms of certain vitamins and minerals that may not be stable or absorbed well from the plant kingdom. If you are willing to pay more for an organic whole food based good multivitamin that also provides the optimal sources and forms of each vitamin and mineral, this is the one. This formula also follows the standards for a vegan multivitamin.
What I like about the 4 capsule version:
- Organic, GMP certified and third-party tested
- No harmful additives or fillers
- Beta carotene from D. salina, a superior source of full-spectrum carotenoids
- Vitamin E as d-alpha-tocopherol and mixed tocopherols
- K2 as a MK-7 from B-licheniformis
- B6 as P-5-P, folate as methylfolate and B12 as methylcobalamin
- A higher amount of magnesium (300mg) and the correct ratio to calcium (125mg)
- Iodine from kelp
- Correct dosing and use of mineral chelates (zinc 12mg, selenium 70mcg, manganese 2.3mg, copper 0.9mg) for a wider population
- While small, the addition of rutin, lutein, lycopene, zeaxanthin, astaxanthin, grapeseed extract, ginger, choline, and turmeric are a nice bonus. Fruit and vegetable blends are small, but provide co-factors.
- Available to be shipped to the UK
What you may need in addition to this multivitamin: True vitamin A which can be obtained from the diet or cod liver oil. Beta carotene needs to be converted to vitamin A, which varies widely in the population. Vitamin C as L-ascorbic acid is more stable and has extensive research has shown it is not inferior to whole food vitamin C. *If you are taking medications, make sure that you do not have any interactions with any of the herbs in this formula (mainly Ginkgo).
Use the coupon code thehealthbeat for 20% off!
I have been searching for a true 100% organic whole food powdered vitamin with stable B-vitamins for years. After many phone calls with the founder – who is a Naturopathic doctor – I am happy to say that Pranin appears to have figured it out. I’m excited to be able to recommend a formulation that contains zero synthetics.
What I like about this one:
- This formula obtains the vitamins and minerals from moringa leaves, carrots, apples, spirulina, beets, red seaweed, spinach, cabbage, kale, collard, guava leaves, parsley, amla berries, lemons, sesbania, holy basil, annatto seeds, Portobello mushrooms, Icelandic kelp, cilantro, horsetail, & mustard seeds.
- Provides nutrients like betaine, choline, lithium, and boron that are often missing in multivitamins.
- Provides superior absorption, co-factors and health-promoting compounds found only in food.
- Add to your smoothie, yogurt or water, eliminating pills.
What you may need in addition to this formula: Since this formula is strictly from plants, you will need to be cognizant of getting enough zinc, vitamin A, vitamin D3, and B12. Vitamin C is also very low. I recommend this formula for women due to the amount of iron (9.2mg). While this amount is small and from plants, I think it is best if Pranin creates a men’s formula with little to no iron. If you are male, I recommend using their Pure-Food B combined with a multi-mineral formula.
Cost: $27.99 for 60 capsules (1-2 daily)
What I like about this one:
- Contains the right form of B12, B6, and folate for everyone including MTHFR mutations. The therapeutic dose is best for those with digestive disorders or seniors.
- Contains 15mg of highly absorbable zinc bisglycinate chelate
- Contains the right doses of manganese, copper and boron
- Uses the correct dosage of vitamin E in the mixed tocopherol form, not dl-alpha-tocopherol or isolated alpha-tocopherol
- Uses natural mixed carotenes (including beta carotene) from the marigold flower
- Uses K2 instead of just K1
- Contains selenium as selenomethionine, not selenate and selenite
- Contains iodine
- Contains a higher dose of vitamin C from L-ascorbate
- Contains 2,000IU of vitamin D instead of 800IU or less
- It requires 2 capsules instead of the 6-8 capsules often required of higher quality multivitamins
- It is affordable. A higher cost doesn’t always mean higher quality, and I try to seek these out for people. It does not contain any harmful fillers or food dyes. I have also found some clients to be sensitive to citrate forms, and this formula does not contain any.
- They are conducting double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trials
- Certified by GMP, TGA from the Government of Australia (Australia’s FDA), as well as by the prestigious NSF International for quality control, purity, and manufacturing.
It should be noted that calcium, magnesium, vitamin C (although 250mg is better than most), choline and omega-3 fatty acids need to be higher in the diet or with supplementation, which is true of every multivitamin. You also may only need 1 a day, reducing the price considerably. While this one is not perfect (there isn’t one) and I still recommend a nutrient target approach along with diet, this will be the best choice for those who prefer a multivitamin.
The Guidelines for Designing Your Own Multivitamin
After doing thorough research on the vitamin and mineral ratios, dietary intake and learning more about the process of certain multivitamins from scientists, I believe the best approach is focusing on minerals and supplementing with a select few nutrients based on your needs while getting the rest from food.
Here is the new article explaining my analysis on how I arrived at this conclusion, how you can determine your needs, and a handy chart for what foods should be consumed for each nutrient: How to Create Your Own Multivitamin with Food.
See the article “How Have We Become So Magnesium Deficient?”
Choose food with a focus on folate, B6 and B12, or B-Complex Plus for methylated B-vitamins important especially for MTHFR/MTR/MTRR mutations.
According to this review, when consumed in increasing amounts in food, six of these nutrients (folate, vitamin B12, niacin, vitamin E, retinol, and calcium) are associated with a reduction in DNA damage, whereas three others (riboflavin, pantothenic acid, and biotin) are associated with an increase in DNA damage to the same extent observed with occupational exposure to genotoxic and carcinogenic chemicals.
Increasing one’s calcium intake further enhanced the genome-protective effect of a high-folate diet whereas a high riboflavin intake further exacerbated genome damage associated with a low-folate diet. This is consistent with epidemiologic studies showing that cancer rates tend to be higher among populations that consume more red meat (which is very high in riboflavin), more alcohol (which depletes folate), and fewer vegetables (a rich source of folate). It is the balance that is important.
MTHFR 677 and MTHFR 1298 Genes
If you have a homozygous MTHFR 677 or heterozygous MTHFR 1298 gene combined with a heterozygous MTHFR 677, you may require higher amounts of folate (600-800mcg in studies) to maintain healthy homocysteine (inflammation) levels and for balanced mental health.
Pregnancy and Folate Intake (Not Folic Acid!)
If you are pregnant, you want to make sure to get adequate folate daily to for a healthy pregnancy, but not too much. A new study from John’s Hopkins University looked at 1,391 mother-child pairs in the Boston Birth Cohort, a predominantly low-income minority population. The researchers found that very high circulating folic acid doubled the risk of autism, and B12 levels that were very high tripled the risk of autism. If both levels are extremely high, the risk that a child develops the disorder increases 17.6 times.
Since folic acid (not folate) was highlighted, this most likely was due to a diet high in processed fortified foods along with supplements containing folic acid, a synthetic vitamin B that does not exist in food. I explain the mechanism behind how this can be problematic in this article.
How to Choose B12
Cyanocobalamin is the synthetic B12 form found in cheap multivitamins and fortified foods. Both folic acid and this form of B12 could be causing methylation issues, leading to high levels of folic acid and cyanocobalamin in the blood, blocking entry into the cell. Choose methylcobalamin, hydroxocobalamin or adenosylcobalamin.
Is there a Whole Food B-Complex?
If you are looking for a true whole-food B-vitamin formula, I recommend using Pranin’s PureFood B, however, you may need more B12. PureFood is also missing biotin. Another option is Pure Encapsulations B-Complex from bacterial fermentation.
Zinc deficiency may affect 2 billion people, due to low levels in our food, the major drop in shellfish and organ meat consumption, and the high intake of grains that block zinc absorption. Zinc is concentrated in the brain, adrenals, eyes and prostate, and disorders of these usually are connected to zinc deficiency. If you are older, diabetic, vegetarian, have low stomach acid or take certain medications, you are even more at risk.
I recommend Zinc Picolinate. Vitamin A and D increase zinc absorption. “A sustained rise in plasma zinc concentration (and therefore its potential bioavailability) was obtained only when the zinc was augmented with both vitamins A and D (in RDA concentrations).” Another reason cod liver oil is awesome.
Research shows that nine out of 10 Americans don’t get enough choline. Choline is required for acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter of the vagus nerve that enervates multiple organs including the lungs, heart, liver, stomach and temporal lobe of the brain. A deficiency could affect all of these.
One study found that women with higher choline intake have the lowest anxiety. Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Syndrome occurs from a choline deficiency. PEMT gene polymorphisms are common in women and increase choline needs even further. Pregnant and nursing mothers require the highest amounts of choline, crucial for a baby’s brain development.
The recommended range keeps changing upward and is currently between 425-550mg for a daily intake up to 930mg for pregnant women in their third trimester. Eggs and liver have the highest amount, followed by meat, fish and smaller amounts in nuts, seeds, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower and collard greens. If you do not eat eggs or organ meats, you are likely deficient and may require Phosphatidylcholine.
See the article Is Vitamin C the Most Important Nutrient for You?
Vitamin A, Vitamin D, and EPA and DHA
The Best Multivitamins for Athletes and High Performing Executives
The Best Children’s Multivitamins
Best and Worst Prenatal Vitamins
Best and Worst Multivitamins for Seniors
How to Make Your Own Multivitamin with Diet
Best and Worst Electrolyte Drinks
Best and Worst Whey Protein Powders